23 Best Broadway Shows: To Must Try On

best broadway shows to must try on

23 Best Broadway Shows: To Must Try On

If you’re anything like me, you want your night out to feel worth it, and picking the right Broadway show is a big part of that. With so many options, it can get confusing fast, but it doesn’t have to be.

In this guide, I’ll walk you through the best Broadway shows to see right now, along with a few helpful pointers so you can find the one that fits your taste.

You’ll get a clear sense of what each show offers, and how to choose the one that feels “right” for you. Let’s make this whole process a lot simpler, and maybe even fun.

What Broadway Shows Are All About

Broadway shows are live performances with big stories, strong music, and talented actors. They happen in famous theaters in New York City.

These shows give you a chance to escape for a little while. You sit back, watch a great story, and enjoy music, lights, and amazing stage moments.

It’s one of the best ways to experience live entertainment, whether you’re a local or a visitor exploring the city.

Best Broadway Shows Right Now

These shows are the most popular and easiest to enjoy. They offer strong stories, good music, and great performances:

1. Hamilton

hamilton best broadway show

Alexander Hamilton grew up with nothing, fought in the Revolution, and helped shape the U.S. government. His talent takes him far, but his choices and pride create enemies, especially Aaron Burr. It’s told through rap, R&B, and big group songs.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Lin-Manuel Miranda, Leslie Odom Jr. (orig.) Jeffrey Seller, Sander Jacobs, Jill Furman 2015–Present

Why you’ll love it: The music feels modern, and the pace is exciting. It turns real history into straightforward, emotional storytelling that people remember.

2. The Lion King

the lion king best broadway show

Simba is a young lion who’s meant to be king. After his father dies, he runs away and grows up far from home. When he learns the truth, he returns to face his uncle Scar and take responsibility. The show is known for puppets, masks, and stage design that turns animals into theater.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Jason Raize, Tsidii Le Loka (orig.) Disney Theatrical 1997–Present

Why you’ll love it: The visuals are a big reason; it’s something you can’t get from the movie. Families also like that it’s emotional but still easy for kids to follow.

3. Wicked

wicked best broadway show

Before Dorothy shows up, two girls meet at school in Oz, Elphaba (green, judged) and Glinda (popular). They become friends, then life pushes them apart. Politics, fear, and rumors turn them into the “Wicked Witch” and the “Good Witch.”

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Idina Menzel, Kristin Chenoweth (orig.) Marc Platt, Universal Stage 2003–Present

Why you’ll love it: Big songs and a story about friendship under pressure. People connect with the idea of being labeled before they’re understood.

4. Chicago

chicago best broadway show

Roxie Hart goes to jail for murder and wants fame more than freedom. In prison, she meets Velma, who’s also a performer. A smooth lawyer turns their trials into a show for the press. Everyone wants headlines, and the truth becomes a tool.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Gwen Verdon, Chita Rivera (orig.); revival stars vary Barry & Fran Weissler (revival) 1996–Present (revival)

Why you’ll love it: It’s slick, funny, and easy to follow. The dance style is a big part of it, and the show still feels current because of the media angle.

5. Aladdin

aladdin best broadway show

Aladdin is a street kid who falls for Princess Jasmine. He finds a magic lamp and meets a Genie who offers three wishes. Aladdin tries to become someone “worthy,” but Jafar wants the lamp’s power. It’s a light adventure with comedy, bright costumes, and big set pieces.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Adam Jacobs, James Monroe Iglehart (orig.) Disney Theatrical 2014–Present

Why you’ll love it: It’s bright, funny, and easy to enjoy even if you don’t watch a lot of theater. The Genie numbers usually get the biggest cheers.

6. Dear Evan Hansen

dear evan hansen

Evan is a high school kid with anxiety who writes letters to himself for therapy. After a classmate dies, Evan gets pulled into a lie that starts small but grows fast. He finally feels seen, but he knows it can’t last.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Ben Platt, Rachel Bay Jones (orig.) Stacey Mindich 2016–2022

Why you’ll love it: Many people see themselves in Evan’s fear and need to belong. The songs capture that feeling clearly and hit hard in the theater.

7. Rent

rent

A group of friends in New York tries to make art and survive while dealing with love, money problems, and the AIDS crisis. Relationships change, friendships get tested, and time moves fast. The show keeps coming back to one idea: don’t waste the days you have.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Adam Pascal, Idina Menzel (orig.) Jeffrey Seller & team 1996–2008

Why you’ll love it: It feels personal and honest, especially the friendships. The songs are memorable, and many people have an emotional connection to its time and message.

8. Sweeney Todd

sweeney todd

Sweeney Todd returns to London after being wronged and wants revenge. He sets up a barber shop and partners with Mrs. Lovett, who runs the pie shop below. Their plan turns deadly. It’s dark, but also has a lot of grim humor and sharp writing.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Angela Lansbury, Len Cariou (orig.) Harold Prince production 1979–1980; revivals

Why you’ll love it: The music is innovative, and the story is wild but still emotional. People also love the dark humor and strong lead roles.

9. West Side Story

west side story

Two teen gangs fight over territory in 1950s New York, the Jets and the Sharks. Tony, linked to the Jets, falls in love with Maria, whose brother leads the Sharks. They try to escape the hatred around them, but violence keeps closing in.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Carol Lawrence, Chita Rivera (orig.) Jerome Robbins production 1957–1959 (orig.); revivals

Why you’ll love it: The songs and dance are famous for a reason. It also feels real because the story is about hate, identity, and choices that spiral.

10. The Book of Mormon

the book of mormon broadway show

Two Mormon missionaries are sent to Uganda. One is confident and by-the-book, the other makes things up to fit in. They try to help a community dealing with serious problems, and their plan goes off track. It’s a comedy, but it also shows people trying to do good.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Andrew Rannells, Josh Gad (orig.) Scott Rudin, Anne Garefino 2011–Present

Why you’ll love it: It’s bold and gets huge laughs without slowing down. The songs are easy to get stuck in your head, and there’s still a real story underneath.

11. Hairspray

hairspray

Tracy Turnblad wants to dance on a local TV show in 1960s Baltimore. When she gets on, she pushes for the show to include Black dancers, too. She deals with bullies, TV drama, and her own doubts, but keeps going. It’s upbeat, but it’s also about fairness and respect.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Marissa Jaret Winokur, Harvey Fierstein (orig.) Margo Lion & team 2002–2009

Why you’ll love it: It’s fun, loud, and full of heart. People like that it tackles real issues while still being a good time.

12. Moulin Rouge! The Musical

moulin rouge the musical best broadway show

A young writer falls for the star performer at the Moulin Rouge. Their love runs into money, jealousy, and the club’s need to survive. It uses many well-known pop songs, mixed into big stage numbers.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Aaron Tveit, Karen Olivo (orig.) Global Creatures 2019–Present

Why you’ll love it: It’s a big night out, music, dancing, lights, and constant movement. People enjoy hearing famous songs used in new ways.

13. Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

harry potter and the cursed child best broadway show

Harry is now an adult, and his son Albus has a hard time living with the Potter name. Albus becomes close friends with Draco Malfoy’s son, Scorpius. A time-travel plan starts as a “fix,” but it creates bigger problems and changes what they thought they knew.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Jamie Parker, Noma Dumezweni (orig. major prod.) Sonia Friedman/Colin Callender 2018–Present

Why you’ll love it: The stage tricks and effects feel unreal in person. Fans also like the focus on friendship and the new characters.

14. Come From Away

come from away

After 9/11, planes were forced to land in a small town in Newfoundland. Thousands of strangers arrive with nowhere to go. The locals feed them, house them, and keep them calm. The show follows many people at once and shows how small acts of help matter.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Jenn Colella, Chad Kimball (orig.) Junkyard Dog Productions 2017–2022

Why you’ll love it: It’s warm, human, and respectful, and it doesn’t drag. People leave feeling hopeful because it focuses on how strangers showed up for each other.

15. Six

six best broadway show

Henry VIII’s six wives take the stage like pop stars. Each one tells her side of the story and tries to prove she had it the worst. By the end, it turns into a conversation about who they were beyond the king.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Adrianna Hicks, Abby Mueller (orig. Bway) Kenny Wax & team 2021–Present

Why you’ll love it: It’s fast, fun, and built for cheering. Each queen gets a moment, and the music feels like today’s pop more than “old history.”

16. Hadestown

hadestown best broadway show

Orpheus falls in love with Eurydice, but she ends up in the underworld to survive. Orpheus follows her and tries to bring her back. At the same time, Hades and Persephone show what happens when love turns cold. It’s a myth told like a music-driven story.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Eva Noblezada, André De Shields (orig.) Mara Isaacs & partners 2019–Present

Why you’ll love it: The music feels different from typical Broadway and pulls you in fast. People also like how it says big things about love and trust without being confusing.

17. Mamma Mia!

mamma mia best broadway show

Sophie is getting married and wants her father to walk her down the aisle, but she doesn’t know who he is. She invites three men from her mom Donna’s past, hoping to figure it out. Old relationships come back, secrets spill, and everything plays out with ABBA songs.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Louise Pitre, Judy Kaye (orig.) Judy Craymer 2001–2015

Why you’ll love it: ABBA fans get what they came for, and even non-fans usually end up smiling. The show builds into a fun, sing-along style ending.

18. MJ: The Musical

mj the musical best broadway show

Set around rehearsals for Michael Jackson’s Dangerous tour, the show follows MJ and his team as they build the concert. You see the pressure, the perfectionism, and the choices behind the music. The story moves through key moments while the stage turns into full performance mode.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Myles Frost (orig. MJ) Book: Lynn Nottage; Dir/Choreo: Christopher Wheeldon 2022–Present

Why it’s loved: People go for the dancing and the hits, and it delivers like a real concert. The pacing stays tight, so it never feels slow.

19. Hell’s Kitchen

hell s kitchen best broadway show

A 17-year-old girl grows up in 1990s Manhattan, trying to figure out who she is and where she belongs. Her mom wants to protect her, but the city pulls her in different directions—friends, first love, and tough choices. The story is told using Alicia Keys’ songs.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Maleah Joi Moon, Shoshana Bean, Kecia Lewis (orig. leads) Alicia Keys (music); Book: Kristoffer Diaz; Dir: Michael Greif; Choreo: Camille A. Brown 2024–Present

Why it’s loved: Viewers say the characters feel real, not “perfect.” It balances fun scenes with emotional ones, so it feels honest and still uplifting.

20. The Outsiders

the outsiders best broadway show

In 1960s Tulsa, Ponyboy and his friends (the Greasers) clash with the richer kids (the Socs). As things get worse, Ponyboy tries to hold onto what’s good—family, loyalty, and the hope that life can change. It’s a coming-of-age story with real stakes.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Brody Grant, Sky Lakota-Lynch (early Broadway cast) Dir: Danya Taymor; Book: Adam Rapp & Justin Levine; Music/Lyrics: Jamestown Revival & Justin Levine 2024–Present

Why it’s loved: Fans talk about how clean the storytelling feels and how strong the performances are. It’s emotional and intense, but it doesn’t feel like it’s trying too hard.

21. The Great Gatsby

the great gatsby best broadway show

Nick moves to Long Island and gets pulled into Gatsby’s world of parties and big promises. Gatsby is chasing Daisy, and everything starts to crack under the surface: love, money, and reputation. The show keeps the classic story but plays it with modern energy and big stage moments.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Jeremy Jordan, Eva Noblezada (original Broadway leads) Book: Kait Kerrigan; Music: Jason Howland; Lyrics: Nathan Tysen 2024–Present (Broadway Theatre)

Why it’s loved: People like the “big night out” feel, music, costumes, and fast-moving scenes. Reviews also mention the cast energy and the clear, easy-to-follow plot.

22. The Phantom of the Opera

phantom of the opera

A young singer, Christine, gets help from a mysterious “angel” who lives under the opera house. He’s a musical genius, but also controlling and dangerous. Christine is torn between him and Raoul, someone she trusts. Secrets and fear build as the Phantom tries to keep her close.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Michael Crawford, Sarah Brightman (orig.) Cameron Mackintosh / RUG 1988–2023

Why you’ll love it: The music is instantly recognizable, even for non-theater fans. People also love the romance + suspense mix and the big stage moments.

23. To Kill a Mockingbird

to kill a mocking bird

Scout grows up in a small town in Alabama and watches her father, lawyer Atticus Finch, defend a Black man accused of a serious crime. The trial exposes the town’s racism and fear. It’s told through Scout’s view as she learns what fairness and courage really cost.

Notable Cast Original Production/Group Broadway Run
Jeff Daniels, Celia Keenan-Bolger (orig.) Scott Rudin / Lincoln Center Theater 2018–2022

Why you’ll love it: The courtroom scenes keep people locked in. It’s also the kind of story that stays in your head after you leave.

How to Choose the Best Broadway Show for You

Choosing a Broadway show is easier when you focus on what you enjoy. These simple pointers help you match your mood or taste to the right type of show:

  • If You Love Big Visuals: Pick shows with bright sets, strong lighting, and big stage effects. These give you a bold, eye-catching experience.
  • If You Want Something Family-Friendly: Choose shows with simple stories and a light mood. They’re safe for kids and still easy for adults to enjoy.
  • If You Prefer a Laugh: Go for musicals with quick jokes, fun energy, and easy plots. These are great when you want something playful.
  • If You Want a Classic Broadway Feel: Look for timeless songs, simple staging, and steady pacing. These shows offer the traditional Broadway style that many people expect.

Quick Guide to Help You Compare Shows

This table gives you a simple way to compare the main factors that set each show apart. Use it to see what fits your taste and budget:

Feature What It Means What to Look For
Story Complexity How easy the story is to follow Simple plots for beginners; deeper stories for drama lovers
Visual Spectacle Size and style of sets, lights, and effects Small, simple staging or big, colorful visuals
Music Style Type of songs used in the show Pop, rock, jazz, classic Broadway, or mixed styles
Kid-Friendliness How suitable it is for kids Family-safe themes or more mature content
Noise Level How loud or calm the show feels Quiet moments vs. loud music and action
Best Seats for Budget Where to sit for a clear view without high prices Side orchestra, front mezzanine, or discounted seating

With these points in mind, it becomes clearer how different shows match different tastes. It also shows how small details can shape the kind of Broadway experience someone enjoys.

How to Get the Best Broadway Tickets

Getting Broadway tickets can feel tricky at first, but a few simple tips make the process easier. These points help you find good seats at fair prices.

Cheapest Days to See Shows:

Weekdays, especially Tuesday and Wednesday nights, are usually less expensive because crowds are smaller. Matinee shows can also be cheaper and still offer the same performance.

Where to Buy Tickets Safely:

Official sites like Broadway.com, Telecharge, and Ticketmaster show real prices and seat maps. Random resale sites often raise prices or list unclear seats, so it’s better to avoid them.

Rush and Lottery Options:

Many shows offer same-day rush tickets at lower prices, usually sold in person. Digital lotteries also offer a chance at discounted seats, which can help if you’re flexible with timing.

TodayTix Tips:

TodayTix often has deals on rush and same-day tickets. The app is simple to use, and price alerts make it easy to track drops.

TKTS Booth Guide:

TKTS booths sell same-day discounted tickets for many shows. The Times Square booth is the busiest, while the South Street Seaport location usually has shorter lines.

These tips make it easier to understand how Broadway pricing works. They also show that good seats are possible without spending more than you need.

Wrapping Up

I’m really glad you spent some time here, and I hope this made the world of Broadway feel a little easier to walk through.

When you break things down, choosing the best Broadway shows becomes less confusing and a lot more enjoyable. It’s a good feeling when everything finally clicks and you know what fits your taste.

This guide was built to help you make confident choices, whether you’re planning a night out or just getting a feel for what Broadway offers.

And if you ever need a quick reminder or want to explore more options, you can always come back for a simple, friendly refresh!

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Written by

Daniel Russo has been obsessed with stories since he wore out his family's VHS collection as a kid. He studied Film and Literature, worked as a script reader, and eventually landed in entertainment writing, where he's spent the last eight years. He covers movies, TV, theater, and the fictional worlds that fans can't stop talking about. Whether he's breaking down a film's themes or explaining why a comic book character matters, his focus is always on what makes stories stick with people.

Daryll Mitchell, a professional interior stylist with a degree in Interior Design from Parsons School of Design, has been with us since 2020. His focus on home accessories is informed by his 12 years of experience in interior decoration.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Keep Groovin’

Daniel Russo has been obsessed with stories since he wore out his family's VHS collection as a kid. He studied Film and Literature, worked as a script reader, and eventually landed in entertainment writing, where he's spent the last eight years. He covers movies, TV, theater, and the fictional worlds that fans can't stop talking about. Whether he's breaking down a film's themes or explaining why a comic book character matters, his focus is always on what makes stories stick with people.

I See Newsletter. I Subscribe.

I See Newsletter. I Subscribe.